Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree Review: A Worthy Expansion

Shadow of the Erdtree adds a new landmass roughly the size of Limgrave and Liurnia combined, introduces Scadutree Fragments as a DLC-specific leveling system, and delivers some of the hardest boss fights FromSoftware has ever designed. It requires defeating Radahn and Mohg before entry, ensuring every player arrives with a late-game character.

How We Reviewed: Our critical take is informed by consideration of the album’s place in the artist’s body of work and evaluation of sonic detail across different playback systems. Ratings reflect extensive playtime, community consensus, and mechanical depth analysis. This content is editorially independent; no brand provided compensation for coverage.

The Scadutree System

Scadutree Fragments function as a DLC-only scaling mechanic. Each fragment increases your damage dealt and reduces damage taken within the Shadow Realm. At zero fragments, DLC enemies hit devastatingly hard regardless of your base game level. Collecting fragments scattered across the map is essential rather than optional, and this system ensures veteran players explore rather than sprinting to bosses.

Revered Spirit Ashes work similarly for summons, increasing spirit ash damage and survivability. Both systems cap at 20 upgrades and create a parallel progression track that rewards thorough exploration of the new map.

Boss Design

The DLC bosses represent FromSoftware’s most aggressive designs. Messmer the Impaler combines a spear moveset with fire magic, mixing delayed attacks that punish panic-rolling with rapid multi-hit combos. His second phase adds serpent-form attacks with completely different timing windows. Learning his patterns requires treating each phase as a separate boss.

The final boss has three health bars and attacks that fill most of the arena. Builds that relied on trading hits through hyper-armor in the base game struggle here because incoming damage exceeds what most vigor investments can absorb. The fight demands pattern recognition and patience over raw stat investment.

Bayle the Dread is an optional dragon boss that many players consider the hardest fight in the entire game. His lightning attacks create persistent ground hazards, his aerial divebombs have enormous hitboxes, and his health pool is massive. The intended approach involves summoning an NPC ally who specifically counters Bayle’s moveset, but finding that NPC requires completing a questline hidden in the map’s upper regions.

New Weapons and Builds

The DLC adds over 100 new weapons including entirely new weapon categories. Light Greatswords offer fast two-hit combos with better range than straight swords. Throwing Blades create a new ranged melee hybrid playstyle. Perfume Bottles scale with specific stats and create AoE effects.

The Dryleaf Arts fist weapon turns the game into a martial arts action game, with a moveset including flying kicks, palm strikes, and a dodge-attack that provides iframes during the strike animation. Combined with the new Dryleaf Blossom Ash of War, it enables a viable unarmed combat build that many players consider the most fun playstyle in the entire game.

Exploration

The map uses verticality more aggressively than the base game. Hidden paths lead to cliffside dungeons, illusory walls reveal entire sub-areas, and the Finger Ruins contain a puzzle involving map fragments that reveal previously invisible locations. The density of hidden content means most players discover new areas on subsequent playthroughs.

The Abyssal Woods area introduces a stealth-horror section where unkillable enemies patrol a dark forest. You must avoid detection rather than fight, creating a pace shift unlike anything in the base game. This willingness to experiment with gameplay genres within a single DLC demonstrates FromSoftware’s design confidence.

Verdict

Shadow of the Erdtree justifies its standalone-game price with map density, boss quality, and build variety that rival the base game’s best content. The Scadutree system could feel more elegant, but it successfully forces exploration over optimization.

The lore implications of Miquella and Messmer expand Elden Ring mythology in directions that recontextualize base game events.

For base game build advice, see our Elden Ring Strength Build Guide. For how Elden Ring compares to other Souls games, check Souls-Like Games Ranked.